New England Historical Fiction:

Our Favorite Novels, with a historical element, set in Massachusetts, Maine, New Hampshire, Rhode Island, Vermont, and Connecticut

The Stargazer of Nantucket

In Julie Gerstenblatt’s historical fiction novel, The Stargazer of Nantucket, eighteen-year-old Winifred “Winnie” Starbuck dreams of leaving Massachusetts behind to join her parents on an epic merchant voyage. Her parents, Peter and Nell Starbuck, are highly renowned trade captains who command the titular Stargazer, a top-of-the-line clipper ship. In 1851, they set out on a […]

The Stargazer of Nantucket Read More »

The Wedding

Set in 1953 on Martha’s Vineyard, Dorothy West’s final novel, The Wedding, explores the insular world of “the Oval,” an exclusive summer enclave for the affluent Black bourgeoisie. The narrative centers on the upcoming nuptials of Shelby Coles, the beautiful, light-skinned youngest daughter of the community’s most prominent family. To the immense dismay of her

The Wedding Read More »

Payton Place

Grace Metalious’s Peyton Place is not considered controversial by today’s standards. But it was a contentious and highly debated novel when it appeared in 1956. It remains a literary phenomenon that exposes the dark, sordid secrets hidden beneath the respectable facade of a conservative New England mill town. Various movie and TV versions of the

Payton Place Read More »

When You Loved Me

In When You Loved Me by Beatriz Williams, a young widow returns to her family’s crumbling Winthrop Island estate, Windward, only to discover it is mired in massive debt. While investigating her father’s tragic death and uncovering long-buried secrets, she reunites with her first great love. Published June, 2026, the story charts Lucy Cooper’s return

When You Loved Me Read More »

The Ice Storm

Rick Moody’s acclaimed novel, The Ice Storm, was written in 1994. It explores the moral and emotional collapse of two affluent, upper-middle-class families in New Canaan, Connecticut, during the turbulent Thanksgiving weekend of 1973. Set against the backdrop of the Watergate scandal, shifting political climates, and the onset of the sexual revolution, the narrative follows

The Ice Storm Read More »

Local Honey Cover

Local Honey

I had a friend write this entry for me. Set in the fictional Merrimack River town of Riverbend, Massachusetts, in 1951, Local Honey is a sweeping historical novel that explores love, class divisions, postwar America, and the struggle for second chances. Against the backdrop of New England’s economic boom following World War II, the novel

Local Honey Read More »

The Vaster Wilds

Set during the brutal “starving time” in 1610, Lauren Groff’s novel follows an unnamed, resourceful teenage servant girl who escapes the disease-ridden Jamestown colony. Fleeing into the unforgiving winter wilderness, she must rely entirely on her wits to survive, navigate her harsh new environment, and find inner freedom. The narrative opens with the protagonist slipping

The Vaster Wilds Read More »